Skip to main content

Why Did God Allow The Holocaust?

The other day I had the honour of spending the day with a group of Holocaust survivors. Myself and the talented Lev Taylor lead a Tu Bishvat Seder in the morning and I was touched by how warm and welcoming the group were to us, two (relatively) young rabbinical students.

In the afternoon we sat down with them to lunch and one of the group told me that, after the Holocaust, she no longer believed in God. She said no God would allow such a monstrous thing to befall people. She also said that since she stopped believing in God she felt that she had lost "her anchor".

This articulate woman then asked me, "how" God could allow things such as the Holocaust to happen?

Whilst I was glad that this lady was able to find some grounding in the Jewish world in which she now lived, I could feel her pain, anger and frustration towards God and her disbelief that people (like me) could champion such a God. I responded by saying that any attempt to justify or explain a 'Godly' reason for such terrible happenings was plain wrong. To even suggest a reason as to why a divine being could have allowed such an event was unhelpful and offensive. I said that she was entitled to her anger with, and disbelief of, such a deity.

Whilst my own notion of God differs greatly from that of this woman our conversation helped me to better understand the unfathomableness of human-inflicted pain and destruction.

As a future rabbi, I will act not as a spokesperson for God but strive to act as a helper to humanity. This brave lady and I concluded this part of our talk by smiling silently at one another before our conversation moved on to other matters...

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Jews In Jewish Spaces

The other day I attended a meeting of cross-communal Jewish organisations. At the table were people who held a range of beliefs and practices. One of the challenges of such umbrella groups is how they accommodate such a diverse range of deeply-held religious ideologies. The inherent tensions of this debate were highlighted during an impromptu discussion as to whether a key feature of a website should remain active on Shabbat or if they should be turned off for all users during this 25 hour period. Though the thing itself may seem trivial the issues surrounding it do have wide-reaching implications. I believe people on both sides of the debate are driven primarily by this simple question; "How can my religious practices and beliefs be accommodated and respected by other people?" The key words here is other for it refers, not to the general non-Jewish population, but to other self-identifying Jews. This type of other often prompts a very different kind of conversation; partic
2 comments
Read more

Children Are NOT Our Future

The other day, as I wrote my bi-annual Cheder Update for the Hebrew School I head up in London, I began reflecting on the larger role of children in Jewish communal life. Over the years, in my conversations with people from a wide-range of communities, I have found some people's preference for their communities to create 'children only' or 'family only' spaces. The logic here - and I do see the logic - is that children disrupt those people who are capable of 'participating' in the 'proper' or 'main' services or activities. Here, children are at best a mild distraction and at worse, a deterrent to fee-paying members. Those who are more sympathetic to families will often remind me that children (and their parents) will find the 'main' service and activities boring and un-engaging. In short, 'main' services are not for them. Instead, they suggest that children and their families should be encouraged to attend cheder (Hebrew sch
Post a Comment
Read more

7 Moments Where Jewish & Other UK Faith Leaders United

As news & social media feeds bombard us with conflict, here are 7 moments to remind us of our shared humanity . 1 Buckinghamshire Faith Leaders from Bahá'í, Christian, Hindu, Jewish, Muslim, and Quaker communities highlighting their mutual friendships and values Click here to read more 2 This gathering of Jewish and Muslim Women who are fighting fight for safety & empathy Click here to read more 3 Archbishop Justin Welby, Sheikh Ibrahim Mogra and Rabbi Jonathan Wittenberg calling for solidarity and unity between communities in the UK, and rejecting any form of hatred or discrimination. Click here to read more 4 Maidenhead Faith Leaders Imam Abid Hashmi, Rabbi Dr Jonathan Romain and Reverend Sally Lynch coming together to foster peace and encourage good relations between the communities amid the Israel-Hamas war Click here to read more 5 This Raw and Honest Conversation Between Two friends - a Rabbi and an Imam Click here to read more 6 The Jewish and Muslim Groups Acknowled
Read more